0

From Monopoly Verdicts to Listicle Purges: What Mediavine’s Leadership Says About the Future of Ad Monetization

This is a newsletter I sent to my subscribers last week. I publish the newsletters on my website; however, I edit out some information from the public versions.

If you’d like to receive these updates in your Inbox in unedited form, sign up for my newsletter:

I just walked out of a closed-door Mediavine webinar where their leadership team shared insights about the future of display advertising. The shift that’s happening could fundamentally reshape how content creators monetize their work in the years ahead 🤓

In an industry where everything can change overnight, staying informed about major shifts isn’t just helpful—it’s vital for survival 👂

The publishers who anticipate and adapt to these changes will thrive, while those caught unaware may find their earnings drop.

According to Mediavine, three important developments stand out as potential game-changers for how we publishers will earn money in the near future:

The Real Story Behind Mediavine’s Listicle Purge

When Mediavine removed hundreds of websites from their network in March, many of us were left confused about why some listicle content was deemed problematic while similar content elsewhere was permitted.

Are all the listicles bad? Should we avoid making them? 🤔

Mediavine’s CEO finally provided clarity: The issue isn’t listicles themselves but how they’re implemented.

Websites publishing exclusively AI-generated listicles that simply repackage others’ content are being flagged as Made for Advertising (MFA) by third-party services 🤷‍♀️

However, original listicles within an overall diverse content strategy are perfectly acceptable by advertisers and can perform well in terms of monetization.

Here’s what it means for us:

• write all sorts of content and not just listicles;
• use your own original content in listicle posts, not just content from others.

Display Advertising’s Surprising Future During Economic Turmoil

Until recently, I believed display advertising would collapse during economic downturns. Did you think so too?

This conventional wisdom is being challenged by current market behavior caused by the tariffs 💸

Mediavine’s CRO (Chief Revenue Officer) shared insights that suggest programmatic display advertising can weather economic uncertainty well ☔

Advertisers are maintaining their typical spending patterns despite the cloudy skies on the financial horizon.

Chinese tariffs represent the most significant potential disruption for advertisers.

However, display advertising is the last thing advertisers want to cut since it directly drives sales. Advertisers have other, higher-priority areas they can reduce first, such as the brand messaging spending or TV advertisement 📺

In other words, display ads are typically one of the last expenses to be cut, so the ad market remains relatively stable despite the financial turmoil. The CRO confirmed that ad inventory sales at Mediavine remain steady 🤑

Some market softening that Mediavines sees may be happening because companies are running out of inventory to sell but don’t want to refill it while they wait for the tariff war to subside.

This is good news for us, but we still have to keep our hands firmly on the steering wheel: produce quality content, demonstrate strong user engagement metrics, and cultivate valuable audience segments.
Don’t chase short-term trends; instead, build sustainable value.

However, if the tariff war continues, eventually the display advertising will be affected as well 🤷‍♀️

The Google Monopoly Verdict: Publishing’s Great Disruption

Do you think Google is an illegal monopoly? I bet you do! 🤓

On April 17, 2025, a federal judge declared what many publishers have long suspected: Google operates an illegal monopoly in digital advertising and must be broken up 🧑‍⚖️

This isn’t just another antitrust headline—it’s potentially the most significant restructuring of the advertising ecosystem in decades. We publishers should be preparing now for a future where Google’s ad dominance is fractured across multiple competitors.

While the immediate implementation will likely be delayed by years of appeals, we should start diversifying our monetization strategies now 🪖 This will help us to capitalize on the coming changes rather than scramble to adapt when they arrive.

As the industry fragments, those of us who have experience across multiple monetization platforms (for example, multiple affiliate programs) will have a big advantage over those who’ve relied solely on Google’s ecosystem.

Fun fact: Mediavine’s CEO Eric Hochberger testified as a witness in this landmark legal case! He found himself in the midst of this important battle 

Now, a question for you!

How are you preparing your websites for these coming changes? Are you diversifying your monetization strategies? Or doubling down on developing premium content that stands out?

Hit Reply, and let’s chat!

Otherwise, have a wonderful weekend ❤️